“We preach tithing to the poor people of the world because the poor people of the world have had cycles of poverty, generation after generation... That same poverty continues from one generation to another, until people pay their tithing.”
I could see saying this about fast offerings. Setting aside and saving a little to help others, no matter how little you have, is how communities thrive and flourish. It's a principle of kindness and sacrifice where the end goal is visible.
This? I'm not sure what to make of this.
I grew up poor. I've gone hungry many times throughout my life, including during years when I paid my tithing. Tithing isn't some magic bullet for poverty and hunger. It's a commandment with a blessing, and the blessing isn't always wealth, financial prosperity, comfort, or ease.
God didn't institute tithing because he needs, or even particularly values, money. Jesus taught that lesson to Peter when he pulled a coin from the fish's mouth. He has only ever needed faith from his disciples to change their circumstances. I hope our leaders remember that, and the African Saints will learn that lesson in their own way, independent of what any leader of the Church says to them.
No
matter what, teaching tithing to financially disadvantaged people will
always have bad optics. It was one of my least favorite lessons to teach
in São Paulo, Brazil for exactly this reason. The knowledge that it
wasn't me asking was the only way I could do it some days.
President
Nelson has the ability to promise nations that if members pay their
tithing, their burdens and cycles of poverty will cease. That would be
preferable over this prescriptive language, in which those who don't
even know about tithing are being condemned for not paying it. Given that some of the wealthiest nations on earth are full of people who also don't pay tithing, this message just isn't going to land in any way that is logical.
I'm
sure President Nelson is doing his best. I'll be praying for him, as I
will for the Saints in Africa. Most people are doing the best they know
how with what they have. And I hope God will look upon all people with
mercy, as he has ever done.
